While both push-to-talk two-way radios and walkie-talkies offer instant, reliable communications, they have their differences based on the team size, business environment, functionality, and operational needs.
What are two-way radios?
Two-way radios are communication devices that allow bi-directional communication involving transmitting and receiving messages. They offer instant, reliable communication, which can be critical in commercial industries, military service, and emergency responders.
Popular types of two way radios include the traditional two way radios (walkie-talkies) and the cellular push-to-talk radios.
What are walkie-talkies?
They are traditional two-way radios that offer instant voice communication across a short to moderate range. Walkie-talkies typically use radio frequencies (VHF or UHF) to receive and transmit voice signals.
Pros:
- Instant communication: They offer communication at the push of a button with zero latency.
- Works off-grid: The radios operate without towers or internet.
- Durable: The devices are rugged and built for factories and construction sites.
- No monthly fees: The radios can be used without any monthly contract.
Cons:
- License requirements: Commercial users need FCC licensing.
- Limited range: Radio coverage depends on terrain and interference.
- Limited features: The radios offer basic features without texting, multimedia, or GPS.
What are push-to-talk cellular two-way radios?
Push-to-talk two-way radios are typically radios that use advanced GPS technology to receive and transmit voice and data through wifi and cellular networks. Instead of radio frequencies, the PTT radios connect users through 4G or WIFI.
Pros:
- Offer nationwide coverage: The radios connected through WIFI or 4G offer nationwide coverage.
- No license needed: There is no need for a license.
- Wide range of features: The PTT radios offer advanced features like GPS, texting, and photo and video capabilities.
- Expandable: The radios can be upgraded to add additional features by upgrading the software or using cloud-based dashboards.
Cons:
- Depends on network availability: The performance of the radios depends on cellular coverage.
- Monthly service fees: The radios work on a subscription model.
What is the comparison between PTT radios and walkie-talkies?
Differences in features:
While walkie-talkies are traditional two-way radios that come with basic features that allow two-way communication, PTT radios have advanced features like GPS, group texting, and voice and data transmission.
Infrastructure requirements:
While walkie-talkies offer a limited range, PTT radios use cellular networks to offer nationwide coverage.
Licensing requirements:
Unlike the walkie-talkies, PTT radios do not require FCC licenses.
Range
Most walkie talkies have a range of about 500 to 1,000 yards, but walls, buildings, and other obstacles can significantly interfere with this range.
Push-to-talk two way radios, on the other hand, have a virtually unlimited range.
Noise and Audio Quality
When you try to extend the range on a walkie talkie, you’ll find that when your devices near their limits, the audio quality will dip and you’ll start to hear static.
The range of two-way radios eliminates static and ensures clear audio messages.
Also, quality PTT two-way radios also feature noise-canceling technology. This allows for clear communication even in the noisiest of environments like at construction sites, amid large crowds, or in high winds.
Durability:
Unlike walkie-talkies, PTT radios are highly durable and are IP-rated up to IP-68. Some, like PeakPTT radios, can survive falls from over 5 feet.
To learn more about PeakPTT two way radios, look over our website or give us a call.855-600-6161, or fill out our online form here.